# The Second Law and Statistical Mechanics

10/04/2007 9:00 AM Broad Institute

Dick Bedeaux, Professor II of Physical Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway

Description: Dick Bedeaux patiently traces the evolution of the second law of thermodynamics from its formulation in the mid"19th century through today, from the perspective of statistical mechanics. In its earliest form, as laid out by Rudolf Clausius, the law states that the entropy of the world always increases. This proposition in some sense launched the field of thermodynamics, according to Bedeaux: "It got going in order to understand exactly where the laws came from." There was particular interest in exploring entropy in terms of the motions of particles. Scientists began refining theories around the behavior of gas in equilibrium, looking at density, velocity distribution, potential energy and heat conductivity. After Maxwell and Boltzmann appeared to have succeeded at a proof of the second law, other scientists questioned its validity: If Newton's equations are reversible, they reasoned, why can't a system in some sense reverse velocities and return along the same path? Others worked out the recurrence paradox, that "if you take any kind of motion in phase space and follow trajectories, that trajectory after a sufficiently long time will come arbitrarily close to the original point" These two paradoxes posed a fundamental challenge to proofs of the second law. The debate continued through the end of the 19th century, into the 20th, with additional efforts to refine the notion of entropy using concepts of probability -- courtesy of the burgeoning discipline of statistical mechanics, according to Bedeaux. This field enabled better descriptions of equilibrium and non"equilibrium states. There was "a lot of progress," says Bedeaux: Einstein explained Brownian motion in 1905, and closer to our own era, scientists "punched a hole in the argument about the recurrence paradox," using probabilistic descriptions. Nevertheless, in our own times, "in non"equilibrium statistical mechanics, there is as yet no fully satisfactory derivation of the second law." To meet this challenge, a proof should provide a simple mechanical example, "like hard discs between reflecting walls, in order to be convincing." While equations of motion on the microscopic level incorporating the idea of irreversibility demonstrate entropy production, it's uncertain "whether Mother Nature believes this herself -- we must do experiments to verify," concludes Bedeaux.

About the Speaker(s): Before his appointment in Norway, Dick Bedeaux was Professor of Physical Chemistry at the University of Leiden, The Netherlands. He extended the theory of irreversible thermodynamics to the description of heat, mass and charge transport along, into and through boundary layers. More recently he worked on the description of curved surfaces in the context of equilibrium thermodynamics. Bedeaux has co"authored the book

Host(s): School of Engineering, Department of Mechanical Engineering

Dick Bedeaux, Professor II of Physical Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway

Description: Dick Bedeaux patiently traces the evolution of the second law of thermodynamics from its formulation in the mid"19th century through today, from the perspective of statistical mechanics. In its earliest form, as laid out by Rudolf Clausius, the law states that the entropy of the world always increases. This proposition in some sense launched the field of thermodynamics, according to Bedeaux: "It got going in order to understand exactly where the laws came from." There was particular interest in exploring entropy in terms of the motions of particles. Scientists began refining theories around the behavior of gas in equilibrium, looking at density, velocity distribution, potential energy and heat conductivity. After Maxwell and Boltzmann appeared to have succeeded at a proof of the second law, other scientists questioned its validity: If Newton's equations are reversible, they reasoned, why can't a system in some sense reverse velocities and return along the same path? Others worked out the recurrence paradox, that "if you take any kind of motion in phase space and follow trajectories, that trajectory after a sufficiently long time will come arbitrarily close to the original point" These two paradoxes posed a fundamental challenge to proofs of the second law. The debate continued through the end of the 19th century, into the 20th, with additional efforts to refine the notion of entropy using concepts of probability -- courtesy of the burgeoning discipline of statistical mechanics, according to Bedeaux. This field enabled better descriptions of equilibrium and non"equilibrium states. There was "a lot of progress," says Bedeaux: Einstein explained Brownian motion in 1905, and closer to our own era, scientists "punched a hole in the argument about the recurrence paradox," using probabilistic descriptions. Nevertheless, in our own times, "in non"equilibrium statistical mechanics, there is as yet no fully satisfactory derivation of the second law." To meet this challenge, a proof should provide a simple mechanical example, "like hard discs between reflecting walls, in order to be convincing." While equations of motion on the microscopic level incorporating the idea of irreversibility demonstrate entropy production, it's uncertain "whether Mother Nature believes this herself -- we must do experiments to verify," concludes Bedeaux.

About the Speaker(s): Before his appointment in Norway, Dick Bedeaux was Professor of Physical Chemistry at the University of Leiden, The Netherlands. He extended the theory of irreversible thermodynamics to the description of heat, mass and charge transport along, into and through boundary layers. More recently he worked on the description of curved surfaces in the context of equilibrium thermodynamics. Bedeaux has co"authored the book

*Optical Properties of Surfaces*with Jan Vlieger. He received his Ph.D. from Utrecht University, Netherlands in 1969.Host(s): School of Engineering, Department of Mechanical Engineering

# Comments (0)

It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. **You can be the first!**

You need to log in, in order to post comments.

- Created
- December 14, 2011 14:04
- Category
- Tags
- License
- All Rights Reserved (What is this?)
- Formats
- H.264 Video (mp4)
- Additional Files

- Viewed
- 4313 times

# More from MIT World — special events and lectures

## The Future of Science and Technolog...

Added 5 years ago | 01:34:00 | 5038 views

## Leadership Lessons Learned on the F...

Added 5 years ago | 00:55:12 | 5351 views

## Keynote: A Conversation with G. Ric...

Added 5 years ago | 00:43:12 | 4888 views

## Network-Driven Transportation

Added 5 years ago | 00:57:15 | 21072 views

## Ingmar Bergman, Cinematic Philosopher

Added 5 years ago | 01:20:00 | 6670 views

## Opening the Mind's Eye" Learning to...

Added 5 years ago | 00:57:25 | 5943 views