Teaching the Second Law
; Howard Butler, former professor of mechanical engineering at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, N.Y., and the retired chair of the ME department at West Virginia University.; Andrew Foley, Associate Professor of Engineering, US Coast Guard Academy; Kim Hamad" Schifferli, '94, Homer A. Burnell Assistant Professor of Mechanical Engineering, and Biological Engineering, MIT; Jeffery Lewins, SM '57, PhD '59, Life Fellow, Praelector, Magdalene College, Cambridge University; Joseph Smith, ScD '59, Samuel C. Collins Senior Professor of Mechanical Engineering; Michael von Spakovsky, Professor of Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Tech; Bernhardt Trout, '90, SM '90, Professor, Department of Chemical Engineering, MIT; Enzo Zanchini, Professore Ordinario, Dipartimento di Ingegneria Energetica, Nucleare e del Controllo Ambientale
Description: Robert Silbey is an old hand at teaching chemistry (40 years and counting), yet each time he turns to the Second Law of Thermodynamics, he's "always very nervous." From this panel of educators, we get a sense of how challenging a classroom subject the Second Law can be.
Joseph Smith notes that the teaching approach "depends on the application," and applications are both theoretical and practical. Students must first ask what is entropy, and why is it needed, says Smith. He focuses on "idealizations that often get ignored," such as isolation, equilibrium and system boundaries. "If we don't get those straight in the beginning student's mind, then there's a lot of confusion."
To Howard Butler's way of thinking, "teaching the Second Law is much more difficult and challenging a task than teaching Newton's Second Law of Motion," both because the concepts involved are so much more complex and abstract, and because the Second Law takes on very different forms depending on which thermodynamic domain is being considered."
Andrew Foley "tries not to worry too much about what entropy is." Instead, he handles the whole concept as if it were an accounting problem: "money being moved through a mint." We can "shove the property of energy instead of money, and produce a form of accounting for energy equations." Says Foley, "First Law, Second Law -- it's all accounting."
As engineering and biology converge, "it's important that students understand the thermodynamics of biological molecules," says Kim Hamad" Schifferli. She demonstrates the Boltzmann distribution with such biological examples as the coiling of DNA from its double"stranded to single"stranded form. Hamad" Schifferli acknowledges that entropy is very difficult for students to grasp viscerally, and that "one thing that helps greatly is the lattice model -- the entropy of mixing two gases, for example."
Bernhardt Trout also invokes Boltzmann, "who believed in atoms vehemently, without substantive proof." This is because "he didn't want to believe in the soul, he wanted to believe we are nothing but matter and motion." Trout says that while we can get a more accurate, mathematical description of atoms, "we owe it to our students to teach them about these most fundamental issues to try to reengage the original questions in the original context in which they existed." br>
Jeffery Lewins reminisces about being "Keenanized" during his college years. He notes that "in the great book, Professor Keenan uses the energy"entropy volume space quite late to discuss equilibrium." Lewins suggests that more can be made of this space in teaching.
Enzo Zanchinidiscusses "a rigorous definition of entropy valid also for nonequilibrium states." He considers closed systems, and lays out a thorough set of basic definitions, going over the First Law and energy, and the Second Law and entropy.
"There are so many textbooks on thermodynamics, so many schools of thought, says Michael von Spakovsky because "there is not a whole lot of agreement on a lot of things." He recounts how a unified theory developed at MIT helped resolve key issues in thermodynamics, by proposing "a broader, self"consistent quantum kinematics and dynamics. Entropy becomes an intrinsic property of matter, including single particles."
About the Speaker(s): Robert J. Silbey joined the MIT faculty as an Assistant Professor in 1966. He became Head of the Chemistry Department in 1990"1995. He was appointed Director of the Center for Materials Science & Engineering in 1998. He served as Dean of the School of Science from 2000"2007. Silbey's primary research concerns the theoretical studies of a) the low temperature thermal properties of glasses, b) energy and electron transfer and relaxation in molecular aggregates, c) the optical and electronic properties of conjugated polymers and d) in collaboration with Professor Field, the dynamics of highly vibrationally excited molecules.
Silbey has received numerous teaching awards at MIT, and has lectured extensively throughout the world. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Chicago in 1965.
Host(s): School of Engineering, Department of Mechanical Engineering
It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. You can be the first!
You need to log in, in order to post comments.
More from MIT World — special events and lectures
Added over 5 years ago | 01:15:00 | 5468 views
Added over 5 years ago | 00:35:08 | 12878 views
Added over 5 years ago | 01:08:00 | 3162 views
Added over 5 years ago | 01:29:00 | 3317 views
Added over 5 years ago | 01:20:00 | 3188 views
Added over 5 years ago | 01:26:00 | 5043 views