Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Sign in

Humanistic Approaches to the Graphical Expression of Interpretation (MIT Communications Forum)

05/20/2010 3:00 PM Bartos theater
Kurt Fendt; Johanna Drucker; Amber Frid"Jimenez; Nick Montfort, SM '98, Assistant professor of Digital Media in MIT Program in Writing and Humanistic Studies

Description: The session begins with brief introductory remarks by moderator Kurt Fendt. He points out the need for new tools that will examine data in meaningful ways through aspects of interpretation and visualization. Dean Deborah Fitzgerald emphasizes the importance of support for digital humanities and visualization interpretation as supplemental to textual analysis, and the creation of new forms of scholarly and cultural communication; Peter Donaldson offers a concise welcome to participants.

It is in sharp contrast to a period of enlightenment and empirical science that a re"humanization of digital activities may now take place, says Johanna Drucker. Humanistic approaches are the motif against which she frames her assertion that "interpretation" introduces an epistemological shift-which she identifies by the rubric "from data to capta"-or data that is taken rather than data which is given.

Noting that visualization techniques originally developed for empirical sciences and quantitative analytics lack the sophistication needed by humanists, Drucker emphasizes that humanists must remember their core orientation and approach interpretation not strictly as visualization. Simply introducing more complicated statistical models doesn't solve the problem, although adding some degree of humanistic inquiry does demonstrate that data is "a composite rather than a singularity." But Drucker identifies the deeper and more serious problem as "not simply a matter of modeling humanistic statistics but shifting the epistemological ground." She sees a serious and substantial role for the humanities "that is cultural as well as intellectual in pushing back against the dominant models of a kind of quantitative and empirical approach."

Drucker advocates a shift from "knowledge" to "knowing" by questioning certain fundamental assumptions about how we know what we know. She and her colleagues have explored this problem by studying temporality and spatiality via the history of time and its representations -- timelines. After searching in vain for means to represent time as non"homogenous -- probabilistic, potential"laden and discontinuous _ she introduced point of view into her models as a way of expressing the subjectivity of temporality _ distinctions in traditional assumptions about time.

Creating graphical representations of humanistic data _ that is, data inflected with affect _ is not data, it's 'capta.' "Capta," she explains, "suggests that all quantification, parameterization, representation is always about an experiential, co"dependent relationship of emergent phenomena. The phenomena don't exist outside of the cognitive perception and the perception is intervening in and influenced by the phenomena."

Ultimately, Drucker suggests, the idea of humanistic experience should be re"centered at the core of the interpretive model. "One of the things we must do," she explains, "is to replace perspective, the human scale, the point of view, the situatedness of human experience within this social and cultural order and it's representation in visual and graphical form."

Kurt Fendt and respondents Amber Frid"Jimenez and Nick Monfort pose questions of their own about the potential for the systemization of visual systems, the difficulty of approaching large, communal data sets, and distinctions between exploration and presentation in the humanities.

Questions from the audience focus on the desirability of certainty within a humanistic construct, and emerging ways in which to represent emergent phenomena thru visualization. Drucker favors the dynamic modeling techniques used in meteorology, because of its potential for layered complexity.

About the Speaker(s): Martin and Bernard Breslauer Professor of Bibliography in the Graduate School of Education and Information Studies, UCLA > Johanna Drucker is among the core scholars who rethink what it means to do humanities research in digital environments. Her research and teaching focus on electronics scholarship, digital aesthetics and visual information design. In 2008"09 she was Digital Humanities Fellow at the Stanford Humanities Center where she worked on a project titled "Diagramming Interpretation." She was one of the co"founders of the Speculative Computing Lab at the University of Virginia, a research group dedicated to exploring experimental projects in digital humanities. She has published extensively on the history of written forms, typography, design, and visual poetics.

She is the author of SpecLab: Digital Aesthetics and Projects in Speculative Computing, (University of Chicago Press, 2009), as well as many other books. In addition to her scholarly work, Drucker is internationally known as a book artist and an experimental visual poet.

Drucker earned her Ph.D., at the University of California, Berkeley (1986).

Host(s): School of Humanities, Arts & Social Sciences, HyperStudio

Comments (0)

It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. You can be the first!

You need to log in, in order to post comments.

More from MIT Communications Forum

Communications in Slow-Moving Crises (MIT Communications Forum)

Communications in Slow-Moving Crise...

Added 5 years ago | 01:57:00 | 27140 views

NBC's Heroes -- Appointment TV to Engagement TV (MIT Communiations Forum)

NBC's Heroes -- Appointment TV to E...

Added 5 years ago | 01:58:00 | 7629 views

Civic Media and the Law (MIT Communications Forum)

Civic Media and the Law (MIT Commun...

Added 5 years ago | 01:53:00 | 25207 views

Politics and Popular Culture (MIT Communications Forum)

Politics and Popular Culture (MIT C...

Added 5 years ago | 02:01:00 | 23553 views

Media in Transition 4: Why Are Stories Violent? (MIT Communications Forum)

Media in Transition 4: Why Are Stor...

Added 5 years ago | 01:19:00 | 5913 views

Why Newspapers Matter (MIT Communications Forum)

Why Newspapers Matter (MIT Communic...

Added 5 years ago | 01:53:00 | 8160 views